Statement
We Oppose Both Saddam Hussein and the U.S. War on Iraq
A call for a new, democratic U.S. foreign policy
Please sign on.
If you have difficulty signing on, please send an email with your name and affiliation (for identification only) to: cpd@igc.org
Joanne Landy, Thomas Harrison, Jennifer Scarlott
Co-Directors, CPD
WE OPPOSE BOTH SADDAM HUSSEIN AND THE U.S. WAR ON IRAQ
A call for a new, democratic U.S. foreign policy
Note: This statement was originally written in November 2002. We told everyone who signed the statement that we would update it once full-scale war broke out, and what follows is the revised version. Only minor changes have been made to reflect the altered situation, e.g. by deleting words like "impending" and "approaching" to describe the war and by eliminating the demand for lifting sanctions, now no longer relevant given the outbreak of the war.
We oppose the U.S.-led war on Iraq, which will inflict vast suffering and destruction, while exacerbating rather than resolving threats to regional and global peace. Saddam Hussein is a tyrant who should be removed from power, both for the good of the Iraqi people and for the security of neighboring countries. However, it is up to the Iraqi people themselves to oust Saddam Hussein, dismantle his police state regime, and democratize their country. People in the United States can be of immense help in this effort -- not by supporting military intervention, but by building a strong peace movement and working to ensure that our government pursues a consistently democratic and just foreign policy.
We do not believe that the goal of the war against Iraq is to bring democracy to the Iraqis, nor that it will produce this result. Instead, the Bush Administration's aim is to expand and solidify U.S. predominance in the Middle East, at the cost of tens of thousands of civilian lives if necessary. This war is about U.S. political, military and economic power, about seizing control of oilfields and about strengthening the United States as the enforcer of an inhumane global status quo. That is why we are opposed to war against Iraq, whether or not it is waged unilaterally by Washington. Even if the attack had been endorsed by the UN Security Council, a body that is unaccountable to the General Assembly, this would only have been a result of bullying and bribery by the U.S.
The U.S. military may have the ability to destroy Saddam Hussein, but the United States cannot promote democracy in the Muslim world and peace in the Middle East, nor can it deal with the threat posed to all of us by terrorist networks such as Al Qaeda, and by weapons of mass destruction, by pursuing its current policies. Indeed, the U.S. could address these problems only by doing the opposite of what it is doing today -- that is, by:
- Renouncing the use of military intervention to extend and consolidate U.S. imperial power, and withdrawing U.S. troops from the Middle East.
- Ending its support for corrupt and authoritarian regimes, e.g. Saudi Arabia, the Gulf states and Egypt.
- Opposing, and ending U.S. complicity in, all forms of terrorism worldwide -- not just by Al Qaeda, Palestinian suicide bombers and Chechen hostage takers, but also by Colombian paramilitaries, the Israeli military in the Occupied Territories and Russian counterinsurgency forces in Chechnya.
- Supporting the right of national self-determination for all peoples in the Middle East, including the Kurds, Palestinians and Israeli Jews. Ending one-sided support for Israel in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict.
- Taking unilateral steps toward renouncing weapons of mass destruction, including nuclear weapons, and vigorously promoting international disarmament treaties.
- Abandoning IMF/World Bank economic policies that bring mass misery to people in large parts of the world. Initiating a major foreign aid program directed at popular rather than corporate needs.
A U.S. government that carried out these policies would be in a position to honestly and consistently foster democracy in the Middle East and elsewhere. It could encourage democratic forces (not unrepresentative cliques, but genuinely popular parties and movements) in Iraq, Iran and Syria, as well as Egypt, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, the Gulf States and Turkey. Some of these forces exist today, others have yet to arise, but all would flower if nurtured by a new U.S. foreign policy.
These initiatives, taken together, would constitute a truly democratic foreign policy. Only such a policy could begin to reverse the mistrust and outright hatred felt by so much of the world's population toward the U.S. At the same time, it would weaken the power of dictatorships and the appeal of terrorism and reactionary religious fundamentalism. Though nothing the United States can do would decisively undermine these elements right away, over time a new U.S. foreign policy would drastically undercut their power and influence.
The Administration's frantic and flagrantly dishonest efforts to portray Saddam Hussein as an imminent military threat to people in this country and to the inhabitants of other Middle Eastern countries lacked credibility. Saddam Hussein is a killer and serial aggressor who would doubtless have liked nothing better than to wreak vengeance on the U.S. and to dominate the Gulf Region. But there is no reason to believe he is suicidal or insane. Considerable evidence suggests that Saddam Hussein is much weaker militarily than he was before the Gulf War and that he is still some distance from being able to manufacture nuclear weapons. But most important, unlike Al Qaeda, he has a state and a position of power to protect; he knew that any Iraqi act of aggression against the U.S. or his neighbors would bring about his total destruction. As even CIA Director George Tenet has pointed out, it is precisely the certainty of a war to the finish against his regime that would provide Saddam Hussein with the incentive he has lacked until now to use whatever weapons he has against the U.S. and its allies.
Weapons of mass destruction endanger us all and must be eliminated. But a war against Iraq is not the answer. War threatens massive harm to Iraqi civilians, will add to the ranks of terrorists throughout the Muslim world, and will encourage international bullies to pursue further acts of aggression. Everyone is legitimately concerned about terrorism; however, the path to genuine security involves promoting democracy, social justice and respect for the right of self-determination, along with disarmament, weapons-free-zones, and inspections. Of all the countries in the world, the United States possesses by far the most powerful arsenal of weapons of mass destruction. If the U.S. were to initiate a democratic foreign policy and take serious steps toward disarmament, it would be able to encourage global disarmament as well as regional demilitarization in the Middle East.
The Bush Administration has used the alleged Iraqi military danger to justify an alarming new doctrine of preemptive war. In the National Security Strategy, publicly released on September 20, 2002, the Bush Administration asserted that the U.S. has the right to attack any country that might be a potential threat, not merely in response to an act of military aggression. Much of the world sees this doctrine for what it is: the proclamation of an undisguised U.S. global imperium.
Ordinary Iraqis, and people everywhere, need to know that there is another America, made up of those who both recognize the urgent need for democratic change in the Middle East and reject our government's militaristic and imperial foreign policy. By signing this statement we declare our intention to work for a new democratic U.S. foreign policy. That means helping to rein in the war-makers and building the most powerful antiwar movement possible, and at the same time forging links of solidarity and concrete support for democratic forces in Iraq and throughout the Middle East.
War has come. But we declare our commitment to work with others in this country and abroad to end it immediately. And we will do all in our power to bring about a democratic and humane U.S. foreign policy.
Partial List of Signers
In addition to the names listed below, more than 5000 people have signed the statement. A list of these and additional names that come in will be posted and updated periodically on this website. All affiliations for identification only.
Name | Affiliation or City or State |
---|---|
The Rev. Patricia Ackerman | Fellowship of Reconciliation (FOR) |
Tanweer Akram | Economist |
Michael Albert | ZNet/Z Magazine |
Barbara Bader Aldave | National Chair, Gray Panthers |
Frederick, M. Anderson | Ann Arbor, MI |
Anthony Arnove | Editor, Iraq Under Siege |
Stanley Aronowitz | Professional Staff Congress, AFT, NY |
Mohammad Z. Babar | Chemical Engineer |
Ben H. Bagdikian | |
Dean Baker | Center for Economic and Policy Research |
Radhika Balakrishnan | Marymount Manhattan College, New York |
Jean E. Barker | Peaceworkers |
David Barsamian | Alternative Radio |
Rosalyn Baxandall | SUNY at Old Westbury |
Gary Benenson | City College of New York |
Medea Benjamin | Founding Director, Global Exchange and Womens Peace Vigil |
Phyllis Bennis | Institute for Policy Studies |
John Berendt | New York |
Marshall Berman | City University of New York |
Michael Berube | Penn State Univ |
Mel Bienenfeld | NYC |
Jean A. Blackwood | Peace Awareness, Carthage, Missouri |
Joel Bleifuss | Editor & Publisher, In These Times |
Rabbi Lewis E. Bogage | DePauw Univ |
Heather Booth | Washington, DC |
Paul Booth | Washington, DC |
Eileen Boris | Univ of Calif, Santa Barbara |
John Bosco | Northampton, MA |
Sam Bottone | San Francisco |
Lila Braine | Barnard Coll, Columbia Univ |
Jeremy Brecher | West Cornwall, Connecticut |
Judith Brody | Washington, D.C. |
Thomas Brody | Washington DC |
Richard J. Brown, MD | Physicians for a National Health Program-NY |
Preston & Ann Browning | U. of Illinois/Chicago(Emeritus) |
Mari Jo Buhle | Brown Univ |
Paul Buhle | Brown Univ |
Judith Butler | Univ of Cal at Berkeley |
Karisa Butler-Wall | Students for Peace in Iraq Now |
James S. Cannon | |
Ellen Cantarow | Medford, Mass. |
C. Carr | Village Voice |
Ramon Castellblanch | SF State Univ |
Patrick Cavanagh | Harvard University |
Dan Chambers | Illinois Education Association |
Charles S. Chapin | |
Paula & Steve Child | |
Noam Chomsky | MIT |
Dennis Clagett | translator/editor, Switzerland |
Joshua Cohen | MIT, Boston Review |
Lynda & Thomas Cowan | |
Margaret Crane | The Write Formula |
The Rev. Robert Warren Cromey | Episcopal Priest |
Amado & Maria Cruz | |
John B Curtin | Vets for Peace, Oregon |
Richard Deats | Fellowship |
Bogdan Denitch | Transtions to Democracy |
Patrick S. Diehl | Vice-Chair, Sierra Club Glen Canyon Group |
Manuela Dobos | Brooklyn Parents for Peace |
Andrew, E. Doe | U.C. Santa Cruz |
Ariel Dorfman | writer |
Ann Douglas | Prof. Of English, Columbia Univ., NYC |
Melinda Downey | New Politics |
Laura Lee Downs | Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences |
Melvyn Dubofsky | Binghamton University, SUNY |
Karen Durbin | writer |
Barbara Ehrenreich | writer |
Carolyn Eisenberg | Hofstra University |
Carolyn Ekeberg | Loveland, Colorado |
Stuart C. Elliott | Kansas Workbeat |
Daniel Ellsberg | |
Said Elnashaie | AU, USA |
Olga Emmel | Wellesley College Centers for Women |
Carlos R. Espinosa | architect |
Gertrude Ezorksy | New Politics |
Sam Farber | Brooklyn Coll, CUNY |
A.W. Farnsworth | Minister, Disciples of Christ, Holla |
Dawn Farrington | SW Colorado Peace & Justice Coalition, Durango, CO |
Liza Featherstone | journalist, New York, NY |
Andrew Feffer | Union College |
John Feffer | writer |
Peter T. Ferenbach | Exec Dir, Calif Peace Action |
Mike Ferro | Oakland, CA |
Barry Finger | New Politics |
John Fischbach | New Orleans, LA |
David L. Fleiss | Washington DC |
Marilyn French | |
David Friedman | Berkeley, CA |
Robert Gabe Gabrielsky | Green Party of NJ |
Janeane Garofalo | North Hollywood, CA |
Barbara Garson | Author Money Makes the World Go Around |
Jack Gerson | Oakland,CA |
Joseph Gerson | American Friends Service Committee - New England Region |
Frances Geteles | NYC |
Mary Gibson | Rutgers Univ. |
Daryl Glenney | Gaithersburg, MD |
Sherna Gluck | Professor |
Malcolm Wofsy Gordon | New York City |
Vivian Gornick | |
Robert M. Gould | Physicians for Social Resp, SF-Bay Area |
Christopher & Coleen Gowans | Astoria, NY |
Susan Griffin | writer |
Brett Gurewitz | Epitaph Records, LA, Calif |
Mina Hamilton | |
LaDonna Harris | Santa Ana Pueblo |
Leah Ida Harris | Jews for Peace in Palestine and Israel, Wash, DC |
Thomas Harrison | Co-Director, Campaign for Peace and Democracy |
Rev. Mark C. Harvey | Grace United Methodist Church, St. Louis |
Howie Hawkins | Green Party, Green Alliance |
Barbara M. and Herbert M. Hazelkorn | |
Judith Hempfling | Yellow Springs, Ohio |
William F. Henning, Jr. | Vice Pres, CWA Local 1180 |
Doug Henwood | Left Business Observer |
Edward S. Herman | Wharton School, Univ of PA |
Michael Hirsch | New Politics |
Pearl Hirshfield | artist-activist |
Martin Hittelman | California Federation of Teachers Vice President |
Adam Hochschild | |
Nancy Holmstrom | Rutgers Univ, Newark |
Niels Hooper | Publisher, Verso |
Jerry Howett | New York City |
John Hyland | Professional Staff Cong, CUNY, AFT |
Doug Ireland | journalist |
Marianne Jackson | Rescue Health Care NY |
Julius & Phyllis Jacobson | New Politics |
Marty Jezer | Brattleboro, Vermont |
Alan Johnson | New Politics |
Virginia Kay | Black Radical Congress |
Wells Keddie | Rutgers Univ |
Robin D.G. Kelley | NYU |
Jean Kemble | psychotherapist |
Mujeeb Khan | DePaul University |
Mel King | Rainbow Coal. Party, MA |
Barbara Kingsolver | writer |
Alexander Kramer | Cellist, Charlotte Symphony |
Merle Krause | |
Tony Kushner | playwright |
Saul Landau | Institute for Policy Studies |
Joanne Landy | Co-Director, Campaign for Peace and Democracy |
Greg Laynor | New Jersey Organizer, Sierra Student Coalition |
Jesse Lemisch | John Jay Coll |
John Leonard | NYC |
Sue Leonard | NYC |
Rabbi Michael Lerner | TIKKUN |
Richard Levins | Harvard School of Public Health |
Mark Levitan | Hoboken, N.J. |
Hal R. Leyshon | President Washington-Orange Central Labor Council (VT) |
Nelson Lichtenstein | UC Santa Barbara |
Mary Lines | Coupeville, WA |
Arthur Lipow | Alameda Peace Action Network |
Gretchen M. Lipow | Peace & Justice Caucus, NEA |
Martha Livingston | SUNY College at Old Westbury |
David L. Mandel | Jewish Voices for Peace |
Betty Reid Mandell | Bridgewater State Coll |
Marvin Mandell | Curry Coll |
Al A. Mangan | Peace & Justice ActionLeague Spokane |
Selma Marks | NYC |
Kevin Martin | Exec Dir, Peace Action |
Timothy Patrick McCarthy | Harvard Univ |
John McMillian | Harvard University |
Jo Ann McNamara | Hunter College, emerita |
David McReynolds | Socialist Party |
Carol Miller | Public Health Activist |
John M. Miller | War Resisters League |
Mark Crispin Miller | New York University |
Ashkan Mojdehi | Students for Peace and Freedom in Palestine |
Kim Moody | Labor Notes Policy Committee |
Rosario Morales | writer |
Toni Morrison | |
Shams-Tabraiz Muzaffar | Dallas, TX |
Ken Nakayama | Harvard University |
Robert Nichols | |
David Oakford | NYC |
Christopher Oleskey | Mount Sinai School of Medicine |
Grace Paley | |
Mitul Patel | Pres, Political ActivistClub,Piano WSr HS, TX |
Ed Pearl | Free Pacifica Neighborhood Network |
Ros Petchesky | WEDO (Womens Environment & Development Org) |
Rima Phillips | Port Townsend Peace Movement, WA |
Frances Fox Piven | Graduate School, CUNY |
Katha Pollitt | The Nation |
Gina M. Portelli | Citizens Standing Against War, KY |
Omar Qureshi | NYC |
Janet E. Rafferty | Chair, Green Party of Mississippi |
Barbara Ransby | Dept of African American Studies, Univ of Ill at Chgo |
Marcus Rediker | Univ of Pittsburgh |
Adolph Reed, Jr. | New School Univ |
Adrienne Rich | |
Sonia Jaffe Robbins | Network of East-West Women |
Leonard Rodberg | Queens Coll |
David Roediger | Univ of Illinois |
Nancy Romer | Brooklyn Coll |
Linda Rosenberg | NYC |
Matthew Rothschild | The Progressive |
Arundhati Roy | SIN(Sweethearts InternationalNetwork |
Edward Said | Columbia Univ |
George Saliba | Columbia Univ |
Lydia Sargent | Z Magazine |
Saskia Sassen | Univ of Chicago |
Max B. Sawicky | Senior Economist, Economic Policy Institute; National Executive |
Charles Scarlott | Tucson, AZ |
Jennifer Scarlott | Co-Director, Campaign for Peace and Democracy |
Jay Schaffner | Treasurer, Committees of Correspondence for Democracy & Socialism |
Andre Schiffrin | The New Press |
Juliet Schor | Boston Coll |
Ellen Schrecker | Yeshiva Univ |
Jason Schulman | co-editor, Democratic Left |
Joel Schwartz | Pres, CSEA Local 446, Staten Island, NY |
Lynne Sharon Schwartz | New York City |
Peter Schwartz | Berkeley, CA |
Timothy Sears | Democratic Socialists of America |
Philip Selznick | UC Berkeley |
Richard Sennett | NYU |
Rabbi Gerald Serotta | Temple Shalom, Chevy Chase, MD |
Stephen R. Shalom | William Paterson Univ |
Adam Shatz | journalist |
Alix Kates Shulman | writer |
Tanya, G. Smith | Oakland, CA |
Ann Snitow | Network of East-West Women |
Sandy Socolar | NYC |
Sid Socolar | NYC |
Alan Sokal | NYU |
Art Spiegelman | cartoonist |
Vernon M Stevens | Veterans for Peace |
Cheryl Stevenson | Boulder, CO |
Elizabeth Stinson | Peace & Justice Center of Sonoma County |
Mark Sweitzer | Colorado Campaign Against War in Iraq |
Bernard Tuchman | NYC |
Robert Vandivier | Minister, United Church of Christ |
Kurt Vonnegut | |
Alan M. Wald | English Dept., U of Michigan |
Robert Waldrop | Oscar Romero Catholic Worker House, Oklahoma City |
Immanuel Wallerstein | Yale University |
Judith Podore Ward | NYC |
Lois Weiner | New Jersey City Univ |
James Weinstein | Founding editor, In These Times |
Cora Weiss | Hague Appeal for Peace |
Peter Weiss | Lawyers Committee on Nuclear Policy |
Thomas Weisskopf | |
Susan Weissman | Saint Mary s College of CA |
Naomi Weisstein | SUNY at Buffalo |
Cornel West | Princeton Univ |
Dorie Wilsnack | |
Reginald Wilson | Am Council on Education |
Barbara Winslow | School of Education and Womens Studies, Brooklyn, NY |
Arnold Jacob Wolf | Rabbi Emeritus, K.A.M. Isaiah Israel Cong, Chgo |
Ira J. Woodward | Reed Student Peace Action Network (RSPAN) |
Kent Worcester | Marymount Manhattan Coll |
Michael Wreszin | NYC |
Anne Zill | Center for Ethics in Action |
Howard Zinn | historian |
Note: New Address
Campaign for Peace and Democracy
2808 Broadway, #12
New York, NY 10025
email: cpd@igc.org web: www.cpdweb.org